Kill Your Darlings
Vita & Virginia
Greetings, dear readers, writers, and trailblazers. I hope November is treating you well so far. The weather is finally feeling correctly cold, it’s getting darker earlier, and for whatever reason, these conditions always inspire me to pick up a book and actually read it. I try my best to read throughout the year, but with my day job and my slightly-unofficial job of watching and writing about movies, it can be a bit difficult to stay steady on a reading path. But all it takes is one good book for me to get in the habit of reading regularly, and I’ve luckily found a few compelling and transportive books lately that have helped me achieve this. It started with Deanne Stillman’s gripping account of a horrifying murder case in rural California titled Twentynine Palms: A True Story of Murder, Marines, and the Mojave—which I’ll be thinking about for awhile. Then I read Emma Cline’s nail-bitingly fun novel The Guest, which I followed up with Sunyi Dean’s brilliant and twisty historical fiction The Girl with a Thousand Faces. I also read Josh Silver’s Fruit Fly, which to me, was only OK, then I read Gwen E. Kirby’s ferociously feminist book of short stories, Shit Cassandra Saw. I know this blog is about movies and not about books, but as an English major, I am trained to report my reading exploits to somebody, and I think everything I read informs my experience of watching movies and writing about them—especially when the movies happen to be about crazy writers and the crazy shit they wrote and did. Around this time last year, I explored a round of films that followed the chaotic and all-consuming love stories of prolific, famous writers and authors, which I titled Literary Love Affairs, and I enjoyed them just as much as I thought I would. Because as much as I delight in reading prose and plots and the occasional poem, I am often even more intrigued by the real lives of these people. Writers and authors still push boundaries and envelopes and say things that have never been said before, but I am endlessly fascinated by the voices of generations past, who really challenged taboos and boldly went where no one else had ever been—both in their writing and in the lives that they lived. I suppose, when you’re bursting at the seams with so many ideas that your pen can hardly write fast enough to express them, you’re bound to engage in a poisonous romantic affair or the odd crime or too—that’s what history has shown, at least! That’s why I was desperate to dedicate another night to films which document and honor important literary figures, their masterful written works, and most importantly, the batshit crazy lives they lived.
Let’s begin with a class of writers that I shamefully knew very little about when I embarked upon this journey, this is the story of the Beat Generation—AKA Allen Ginsberg, Lucien Carr, Jack Kerouac, and William S. Burroughs—and one of the darkest chapters of their lives as told by screenwriter Austin Bunn and director John Krokidas in their 2013 film Kill Your Darlings. As if the title—which references the oft-misquoted advice of Arthur Quiller-Couch, suggesting writers must be willing to remove their most finely written passages if they fail to serve the piece as a whole (technically “Murder your darlings”)—weren’t ominous enough, Kill Your Darlings opens on a younger man holding the seemingly dead body of an older man in dark waters, before the younger man is locked up in jail. He is begging his friend on the other side of the bars to help him, but his friend walks away as the pleading screams get quieter. We then cut back in time, to Paterson, New Jersey in 1943, where a 17-year old Allen Ginsberg (Daniel Radcliffe) is keeping the peace between his fellow poet of a father, Louis (David Cross), and his paranoid schizophrenic mother, Naomi (Jennifer Jason Leigh.) This tension and tumult is interrupted, however, when Allen receives a letter in the mail, and learns that he has been accepted into Columbia. Before he can even daydream about what his undergrad experience may be, Allen is thrust into the hustle and bustle of this New York City campus full of intellectuals and idealists and other idiosyncratic, imaginative minds like himself. He immediately butts heads with his English professor, who claims that foundation and form are essential to poetry, though Allen argues that Walt Whitman eschewed traditionalist form and wrote all over the place. Allen is clearly not afraid to speak his mind, but when he witnesses a young man named Lucien Carr (Dane DeHaan) jumping on tables in the library and quoting the cock-centric writings of Henry Miller, he finally finds a friend. Allen and Lucien get on like a house afire—“finally, an oasis in this wasteland”, Lucien says to Allen—and eventually Lucien takes Allen down to the “land of the fairies” (the East Village) to meet the cigarette-smoking, drug-taking, bold beatniks and ostentatious artists who are all on the cusp of creative greatness. Lucien is trying to form a bit of an intellectual posse, comprised of himself, rich kid William S. Burroughs (Ben Foster), and eventually the jock-turned-author Jack Kerouac (Jack Huston.) This gang is far too busy going to parties and brainstorming and snapping along to jazz to go to class—not that this effects Lucien, who has all of his school work done for him by his toxic situationship, a janitor at Columbia named David Kammerer (Michael C. Hall), who is always just on the outside of Lucien’s cliquey exploits. As Lucien laments that American soldiers are off fighting foreign fascists while local fascists invade their creative spaces as home, Allen declares that their special group needs a name, like the Dadaists who came before them—and thus, “The New Vision” is born. Burroughs is inhaling nitrous, Kerouac is tossing the pigskin, and Allen and Lucien are deep in an artistic, flirting-with-physical love affair which involves mad writing sessions and pretending to hang themselves and smoking lots of weed and cigarettes. While Allen and Lucien make bedroom eyes at one another, clearly enamored with one another’s brains, the spectre of homosexual punishment is lingering around them, as their lively jazz clubs are sometimes interrupted by police apprehending gay men who were in the wrong place at the wrong time. It’s an odd, claustrophobic juxtaposition, as even the most open and radical minds we’re presented with here also clearly felt great fear and resistance to their own sexual expression, regardless of how liberated their writing suggested them to be. It’s all fun and games and pranking the librarians until Lucien’s toxic situationship turns into a scorned lover, and someone eventually ends up dead. Kill Your Darlings is a fascinating, frenetic, highly-stylized and (thankfully) hyper-sexualized, practically-dark-academia-fanfiction-except-it’s-real story about a wild, revolutionary chapter in literary history and American culture, where the anti-capitalist renegades raged against conservative society and the policing of moral goodness, all while juggling their own intense, interpersonal dramas. My sister described this film as “Party Monster for intellectuals”, and I couldn’t agree more. The members of The New Vision even recognized the cinematic quality of this insane moment, because several members wrote stories about this time period and this murder that rocked their friend group. Kerouac’s The Town and the City is a fictional retelling in which Carr is represented by the character “Kenneth Wood”, and a more literal depiction of events appears in Kerouac’s later story Vanity of Duluoz. Soon after the killing, Ginsberg began a novel about the crime, which he called The Bloodsong, but his English instructor at Columbia, seeking to preclude more negative publicity for Carr or the university, persuaded Ginsberg to abandon it. In 1945, Kerouac and Burroughs wrote And the Hippos Were Boiled in Their Tanks, a novel all about these dark events, but it wouldn’t be published and viewed by the public until November 2008. I highly, highly suggest you read more about the Beat Generation, the reverberations of their literary and cultural influence, and this particularly chaotic point in time, because it is all even stranger and more macabre than what is shown in this film. That being said, I was completely blown away by Kill Your Darlings, by it’s biting and bitchy script, and by its fearless performances. Everyone is so brilliantly-well-cast, I was shocked to learn that Jesse Eisenberg, Ben Whishaw, and Chris Evans were originally cast as the leads. And with all due respect to those boys, I really enjoyed this ensemble—particularly Daniel Radcliffe, who kicked off his dauntless and unique post-Harry Potter career with this wild film. And not for nothing… I have never been attracted to Daniel Radcliffe, but here, with his brown contact lenses and perm and defiance of literary form, I was positively smitten. His chemistry with Dane DeHaan fueled this thrilling film, and all of the supporting players—like Kyra Sedgwick and Elizabeth Olsen and David Rasche—were just the cherries on top. John Krokidas did such a superb job directing this movie that I am baffled to say that, as of this writing, this is his only feature film. I love stories about the messiness of brilliant, historical minds, and Kill Your Darlings showcased this fabulously, with just the right amount of demon twinkness and linguistic pretentiousness. Again, I could write so much more about these interesting people during this interesting period of time, about how Ginsberg ultimately became a bit of a frustrating, hypocritical counter culturist, but I fear I wouldn’t be able to stop myself, so I’ll just tell you again to read about these crazy clever people, and watch this crazy clever movie.
Up next I explored a far less chaotic but still thoroughly controversial story, one that follows a different group of literary libertines from a just a couple decades before the Beat Generation, this is Chanya Button’s 2018 film Vita & Virginia. I only recently learned about the iconic writer and liberationist Vita Sackville-West from my research of the film Orlando—a character and story inspired by Vita, which was written by her lover, the immensely talented Virginia Woolf. As someone who majored in English and minored in Feminist Studies, it would be fair to assume that I’ve read Virginia Woolf and know everything about her, but sadly, this is not the case. Beyond my love for the film Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, which actually has nothing to do with Virginia Woolf, she is unfortunately rather unknown to me. For whatever reason, her literature never crossed my desk (apart from the random, beautiful quote every now and then), and I am only just now reading her work. My best friend kindly gifted me my own copy of A Room of One’s Own for my birthday, and since I’m finally reading that, it seemed like the perfect time to learn about the complicated love affair that inspired Virginia Woolf’s most prolific period, the romance that makes one question, who, exactly, was the muse here? Vita & Virginia opens on a cozy house where a printing press is steadily churning out copies of Jacob’s Room, Virginia Woolf’s latest novel. In this same cozy house, Virginia Woolf (Elizabeth Debicki) has shut herself into her office so she may work, but she is also tuning into a radio broadcast where author Vita Sackville-West (Gemma Arterton) and her husband, British politician Sir Harold George Nicholson, are having a discussion about their very modern marriage. “I didn’t sign a marriage contract, I negotiated one. Would you agree?”, Vita asks, to which her husband responds, “Yes. Marriage is a living organism, more like a plant, in need of constant nurture” he answers. “Men tend to regard themselves the plant, and women the soil. But I feel masculine”, Vita retorts, and as Virginia listens, alone in a room of her own, she smiles. Vita drives off in her car, Harold drives off in his, and the two display a level of comfort and trust in one another that no-doubt puzzled 1920s British society. But despite their ultramodern, ultra chic open relationship, Vita is still committed to being a good wife, mother, and writer. Vita cannot stop talking about Virginia’s latest book and her many talents, and her mother, Lady Sackville (Isabella Rossellini), teases (with some intensity), “I hope you’re not thinking of running off with her too…” Vita rolls her eyes and explains, “I promise that wont happen again. And I only pretended to be a man to get my novel published, you know that!” casually brushing off what sounds like a truly fascinating and transformative era of Vita’s life. One evening, Vita attends a fancy dress party that is rather bohemian, even for her, and when she spots Virginia on the dancefloor—pants on, hair down, dancing with abandon—Vita is positively spellbound. I am obsessed with the way their meeting was shot, choreographed, and presented. When I envisioned the cinematic retelling of this 1920s era lesbian romance, I sort of expected clutched pearls and silent tears and somewhat fruitless yearning, but the fact that the meeting of these two lovers is captured as if they’re teenagers who lock eyes at a party or club and instantly connect as the music booms quieter and quieter around them, just made me so happy. (Both of tonight’s films utilize modern music in their scoring, but in Vita & Virginia, musician and composer and sister to Phoebe Waller-Bridge, Isobel, found a way to use Elizabeth Debicki’s actual heartbeat in the score for the film.) From there, it is not the easy courtship that Vita is perhaps used to, and though Virginia is impressed by Vita’s writing, she seems disinterested in her lifestyle. There is immediate longing in both of their eyes, and consistent yearning (as I thought), but Virginia plays hard to get for the majority of this story, despite the fact she, too, was a very modern, liberated woman who wasn’t exactly obsessed with heterosexuality. Vita is under Virginia’s unintentional spell, and Virginia aptly remarks once that, “I often think romance is just not knowing a person; it’s the not knowing that drives someone mad.” It would be impossible for even the aloof and distant Virginia Woolf to not notice Vita’s insatiable appetite for her attention, because Vita doesn’t just invite Virginia to luncheons and to join her writer’s club, on multiple occasions Vita fully tries to get Virginia to run away with her. It’s not until Vita goes away for an extended period of time to perform diplomat’s wife duties that Virginia lusts after Vita, too. While they are apart, the two modern women write to each other constantly, and these letters are what the majority of this film is based upon. Not since Dracula have I heard such kind, romantic, desperately horny words uttered, and eventually, Virginia recognizes that her fear of letting go, her fear of exploration, her fear of herself, is no match for her desire to be with Vita. So the two carry on a sexy, sweet love affair that their respective husbands seemingly have no real problem with, though Virginia’s husband Leonard and her sister Vanessa (Emerald Fennell) do worry how Vita’s eccentricity will affect Virginia. But even when Vita does break Virginia’s heart, Virginia’s writer’s block is cured and she is inspired to write Orlando about her—she is the same cogent writer but with even more experience and a wider capacity for pleasure under her belt now. I don’t want spoil any more of this film, but I will tell you that much like Kill Your Darlings, I was pleasantly surprised to learn that the drama that broke up these whirlwind romances somehow didn’t end the friendships entirely, and Vita and Virginia remained friends and confidants for many years after. As much as I enjoyed the roaring twenties romance between two trailblazing feminist titans, I have to say that I enjoyed Kill Your Darlings just a little bit more, but it’s not a contest. I love all of my convoluted, libertine, literary icons equally, but if a movie actually made me attracted to Harry Potter, that’s gonna be the bigger headline. Besides, as I learned in my research, Allen Ginsberg was a vocal advocate for pedophilia and Virginia Woolf was an adamant antisemite, so whatareyagonnado! I guess we must kill our darlings and never meet our heroes because idk what they were smoking. Well, I guess I kinda do know what they were smoking, but that’s beside the point. Any time I’m ever displeased with my own writing, I wonder if I just haven’t had enough life-altering experiences, but then I watch movies like these and think, you know what… maybe I’m okay with being mediocre. Well that’s enough words about writers and their words but I appreciate you reading and learning along with me! Until next time, I’ll leave you with Lucien Carr’s alleged mantra: “Make ‘em laugh, make ‘em cry, make ‘em horny!”